How is a whip viewed as a weapon

Whip - gun law situation

  • Hello everyone,

    how is a bull whip to be classified under gun law? It is not mentioned in the weapons law - at least I did not find anything about it.

    At close range, probably only useful for choking, but at the right distance and with the appropriate skill, a bull whip should be capable of causing some damage.

    What about leadership?

    Who finds spelling mistakes may keep them

  • Japanese chopsticks and hair curlers are also not mentioned in the gun law, but they can certainly hurt someone.

    Guys, don't give politics any new ideas for bans.

  • At close range, probably only useful for choking, but at the right distance and with the appropriate skill, a bull whip should be capable of causing some damage.

    What about leadership?

    This applies to my hands, as well as to a number of other objects ..

    No, seriously, if you round up a herd of cattle on your farm, no one will be interested.

    May I ask why you want to keep a bullpeak (readily accessible)?

    Then the question might be easier to answer ..

    mfG Long

    P220X-Six .45ACP Gen.1 with WS.9mm + .22lfb, S & W686 International converted to TC

    "I am what I am. Some know me, others know me. "

    Konrad Adenauer

  • Hello everyone,

    how is a bull whip to be classified under gun law? It is not mentioned in the weapons law - at least I did not find anything about it.

    At close range, probably only useful for choking, but at the right distance and with the appropriate skill, a bull whip should be quite capable of causing some damage.

    What about leadership?

    I don't think so now. Do you now want to query every object for conformity with the weapons law? : wall :: wall :: wall:

    What's going on in your mind? You can no longer be very tight, so I recommend a visit to a suitable doc.

    Whoa, if these are our gun owners, all I can do is run away screaming. : wall :: wall :: wall:

    Happy trails

    Texas Jack

    SASS life # 55314

    BDS Western # 625

    "Cowards never lasted long enough to become real cowboys"

    Charles Goodnight

  • Well,. You don't have to get excited about the question right away.

    After all, Marlinman is not a vacation-related debutant who comes with the most absurd question as an introduction.

    Without quoting the exact text of the law (because I don't feel like looking for it just before going to bed ...), such a whip is a suitable object in terms of its nature and purpose to harm someone or to reduce one's defensibility. That’s what it was made for. Not for people, but also works there (very well). So to see it as a weapon ...?

    I wouldn't just walk into the pedestrian zone with it or pick up my child from kindergarten.

    First of all, it is probably rather embarrassing to walk around with it, secondly, an LWF can lose its reliability with something like this.

    I can't think of a "species-appropriate" explanation why you have to have it with you .... a recognized purpose that is not only required for knives, but also for other dangerous objects, would also be useful for a whip .. otherwise: need to explain ...

    Jens

    I share my knowledge with you here and represent my opinion.
    My knowledge can contain errors, my opinion does not have to correspond to yours.
    Correct my mistakes with your knowledge. Good arguments can influence my opinion.
    Lived forum ... that's how it has to be!

  • but at the right distance and with the appropriate skill, a bull whip should be capable of doing some damage.

    and after the 1 blow YOU then have a really angry wild boar on you, which then attacks you even more, because the bull whip needs the right distance and causes pain there - but has no stopping effect.

    Until you can handle it properly (so that you hit it in a targeted manner at all), you can train a lot.

    Those who used something like that in non-mutual consent always had WEAPONS if the person hit did not kiss because the whip is an instrument of punishment but not a weapon of defense.

  • suveran

    I'm not upset, I just can't believe it.

    Will you soon also be asked what the situation is like when I am out and about with a walking stick? I can use it to cause serious damage to someone in a pedestrian zone or reduce their ability to defend themselves.

    Have you ever worked with a whip like this? It was not developed to harm people or animals, it was created as a tool for shepherds to direct the cattle. As with so many other things, the side effect came out of it as a weapon.

    This post amazes me precisely because Marlinman always gave me the impression that I was in life. What trip is he on ???

    Happy trails

    Texas Jack

    SASS life # 55314

    BDS Western # 625

    "Cowards never lasted long enough to become real cowboys"

    Charles Goodnight

  • Without knowing the background of the question and what he wants to do with the whip, but imagine there is an event (e.g. western event) where someone cracks a bull whip for fun. And there are Greta's relatives, of all people, who are really outraged: devil: (as always) and report you for cruelty to animals (it's a whip, you hit animals with it) and for carrying a dangerous object in public (because that yes not at all and is dangerous and phous). And now let's assume for some absurd reason the whip is actually seen as a weapon, you do not have a permit for the event and an unfriendly SB at the authority ... then the trouble is there. So Marlinman's question may be justified. Even if there are a lot of "unds" here.

    Maybe Marlinman just shot the question about the 5th wine: drink: in his head and he wanted to know.

    So ... I don't know the answer to his question.

  • Ok guys, I didn't want to drive a pig through the village, and I drink a maximum of one glass of wine per evening, otherwise I'm in a coma ..: mk:

    The question arose from a discussion with a club colleague who, as already suspected, is a farmer and has such a device. I don't have a whip myself, and I don't intend to get one.

    At best an SRS weapon, if I should ever have use for such a toy: drink:

    Who finds spelling mistakes may keep them

  • Ok, after all the experts have let off their steam here, let's get down to business. In several major cities in Germany there are associations of bullwhip lovers who like to crack outdoors. A group meets regularly in a park in Berlin and trains in public. The police came in a couple of times, but only to observe. Ergo, there is nothing on the part of the law. It's just an unusual picture. For self-defense, such a whip over 2m is rather impractical, but it makes a lot of noise. Have one yourself made of paracord and crack again in the garden or outdoors.

    Contents from external sites are not automatically loaded and displayed without your consent.
    By activating the external content, you consent to personal data being transmitted to third-party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our data protection declaration.
  • Well, then the subject is probably through ...

    :: c.o.l)

    J.

    I share my knowledge with you here and represent my opinion.
    My knowledge can contain errors, my opinion does not have to correspond to yours.
    Correct my mistakes with your knowledge. Good arguments can influence my opinion.
    Lived forum ... that's how it has to be!

  • Hmm, and I thought Indiana Jones was among us. .. The scene 'I don't have time for that now'

    I still remember. But Indy used something else.

    Marlinman, if you ask such questions, it will be easier for us if you explain the background so that we don't have strange thoughts.

    So thank you! I also raised my eyebrows (Spock moderately) when I read this

    : hyster:

    --
    State officer BDMP Hessen for DP DR SAR -, plus ProLegal and Jäger in the HLJV

    Those with the loudest opinion often have no idea.

  • But Indy used something else.

    Indy uses a so-called carbachute.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Who ned liabt and who ned laughs, who makes nia kloane mistakes,

    if you don't eat and drink at the same time, you are alive and well.

  • Contents from external sites are not automatically loaded and displayed without your consent.
    By activating the external content, you consent to personal data being transmitted to third-party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our data protection declaration.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Who doesn’t liabt and who doesn’t laugh, who doesn’t make mistakes,

    If you don't eat and drink at the same time, you are alive and well.

  • The "Chlauschlöpfete" is known in various rural regions of the Argaus on December 6th. The walk of St. Nicholas with his presents is accompanied by the male village youth with the crack of a whip. One of my childhood friends had my grandfather build a short leather spear out of a "Munifiesel" (bull penis). While practicing with this device, he lost his right earlobe.

    Mitr

    I am immune to marketing. For this reason I don't drink Red Bull and I don't have any weapons from H + K!